While viewers are promised that each edition of The Bachelor or The Bachelorette is the most dramatic one yet, that actually might have been the case for Matt James' Season 25.
Season 25 broke new ground for the franchise in a multitude of ways: Matt James was the first Black lead on The Bachelor, and the contestants included 25 women. several of whom identify as BIPOC.
Off the show, internet sleuths discovered that contestant Rachael Kirkconnell had attended an "Old South" antebellum-themed party in 2018 and that she had liked several posts showcasing instances of cultural appropriation.
Several people who claimed to be her former high school classmates also accused her of being a bully. She issued an apology for her actions on Instagram on Feb. 12, 2021.
While defending Rachael in an Extra interview with former Bachelorette lead Rachel Lindsay, host Chris Harrison asked viewers to have "compassion" for her actions, and used the term "woke police."
After Chris issued one apology, a petition began circulating, calling for his termination from ABC. In his second apology, he announced that he would take a step back from the show to educate himself on being anti-racist.
With all of that said, fans learned that Matt ended up offering Rachael his final rose. But given the recent controversy and Matt's claims that they are no longer together on the After The Final Rose special, fans thought they were done.
But then, photos surfaced of Rachael and Matt spending time together, and fans were convinced that they were back on.
Social media users initially believed that Matt and Rachael had reconciled.
The After The Final Rose special was very emotional, with Matt facing Rachael for the first time since their breakup. He took the opportunity to explain to the world the hurt he felt over the controversy.
But many fans believed that Matt's wounds had healed and that he'd patched up the relationship. RealitySteve (the prime source for all things Bachelor-related) tweeted on April 6, 2021 that Matt and Rachael were in New York City together, info that fans took and ran with.
If you're familiar with RealitySteve, then you know that he is almost always right when it comes to reality television. After all, he did say that Katie Thurston was going to be the next Bachelorette and he turned out to be right. Plus, other photos of Matt and Rachael surfaced online.
After much back and forth, it seems the couple is pursuing a relationship again.
There was some deliberation as to whether all of these photos constituted the couple's reconciliation, and initially, a source told Page Six the pair were simply friends.
“Matt and Rachael are not back together,” a source told the site. “They are working on building a friendship outside of the show and away from the noise. The past few months have been extremely difficult for Matt.”
There were even rumors of another woman in the mix, as Matt's former fling, Grace Amberling, reportedly reached out to Matt and asked him to come see her in NYC.
In an Instagram Live with RealitySteve, Grace told Steve that she and Matt had initially met while he was in Florida. Upon hearing that he had been cast for The Bachelor, Grace shared that Matt wanted her to appear on the show, but she declined.
Grace also revealed that Matt contacted her "out of the blue" while he was in New York to try and get her to fly in for the night. But of course, she declined that, too.
"It just didn't sit right with me," Grace said. "I just felt like Rachael was so in love with him and for him to be trying to contact me and hang out with me – someone he's had past romantic relationships with – two days prior in Miami... I felt like I had to say something for Rachael's sake."
But by the end of April, Matt confirmed that he and Rachael were pursuing more than a friendship again.
"I've seen Rachael a handful of times," he told People. "I'm not pursuing any relationships right now outside of that. I said I was going to focus on my relationship with her and that means focusing on it."
Rachael initially felt "manipulated" by Matt after hearing Grace state publicly he had asked to see her, but a source told Us Weekly that she's "giving him another chance."
“Matt felt bad about what happened between him and Rachael and so he reached out to her saying he wanted to see her," the source said.
When Matt was asked if Rachael had addressed and grown from her previous problematic behavior, the former Bachelor said "that's something you could talk to her about."
Clearly, things are still rocky between the pair, but it's still possible they'll get back together.