'Love Island USA' Cast Member Cashay "Cash" Proudfoot Was Eliminated by Charlie Lynch — but Is She Single Now?

On Episode 23 of 'Love Island USA,' Cash was eliminated when Charlie Lynch picked Alana Paolucci. He felt that Cash still had feelings for someone else.

Toni Sutton - Author

Aug. 11 2021, Published 11:22 p.m. ET

Cashay making an entrance on 'Love Island'..
Source: CBS

The American version of the popular U.K. reality dating show Love Island debuted its third season in July and has been the sizzling summer series to watch on CBS. Audiences have been watching beautiful people in bathing suits looking for their perfect match while living in the lap of luxury in Hawaii.

Article continues below advertisement

Contestants while on Love Island USA are isolated from the rest of the world and are put under continuous surveillance, living together much like the style of CBS's sister show Big Brother. To stay on the dating show, contestants must "couple up." Sometimes they're seen playing silly games, going on dates, but most of the time, they are hanging by the pool in the day and partying it up by night.

Cast Member playing a game on 'Love Island'.
Source: CBS
Article continues below advertisement

Those that don't find a connection may be dumped, which means they are eliminated from the island. In Episode 23, viewers were totally shocked when fan-favorite Islander Cashay "Cash" Proudfoot was eliminated. Here's everything we know about the situation.

What happened to Cash from 'Love Island'?

Cash was a fan favorite Islander, and fans were not pleased with what happened to her. The reality show's fans were rooting hard for the waitress from New York to take home the whopping $100,000 prizemoney and be crowned the Season 3 winner of Love Island. However, her decision to pick Charlie Lynch and not Melvin "Cinco" Holland didn't end up paying off for her.

Article continues below advertisement

In Episode 23, the new coupling came down to Charlie and two girls that he was attracted to — one being Cash and the other newcomer Alana Paolucci. Charlie ended up picking Alana and dumping Cash. He decided to eliminate her because he felt that it would never have worked out between them. Charlie knew that she still had feelings for Cinco.

Cash crying on an episode of 'Love Island'.
Source: CBS
Article continues below advertisement

Where does Cash and Cinco's relationship stand today?

When Cash was eliminated from Love Island, she hoped that it wasn't too late to work things out with Cinco and that he would want to talk to her. In an interview with After the Island, Cinco had this to say about fixing everything with Cash: “It’s totally up to her. I’m definitely open to talk to her, but I will leave the ball in her court on that one. I’m sure about that one.”

Luckily for both of them, they were able to reunite in an airport. Per Us Weekly, Cash took to social media on Aug. 8 and posted a video to her Instagram account. In the video she says, “I’m on my way back to my hometown and guess who I ran into?” The video shows her and Cinco laughing together.

Article continues below advertisement
Cash and Cinco talking with each other on 'Love Island'.
Source: CBS

She goes on to say, “We finally saw each other. ... Thank you guys so much for all the support and all the messages. We’re figuring it out but no pressure, please. We’re just chillin’ and we’re gonna see what happens.”

Love Island USA airs Tuesdays, Wednesdays, Thursdays, Fridays, and Sundays on CBS at 9 p.m. EST.

More from Distractify

Latest Love Island News and Updates

    Opt-out of personalized ads

    © Copyright 2023 Distractify. Distractify is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.