Bobbi Althoff Is Still Going Strong With Her Mystery Man — Who Is She Dating?

Regardless of what you think about her — whether or not she's an industry plant is a hotly debated topic — podcaster and influencer Bobbi Althoff is no stranger to making headlines. Her star status first exploded following her viral interview with Drake in 2023, which sparked rumors of an affair with the rapper.

Months later, it was announced that Bobbi and her husband of four years, tech executive Cory Althoff, were getting a divorce. This, of course, only fueled the allegations of her affair with Drake even further.

Now, though, in her first semi-public romance since the dissolution of her marriage, Bobbi has teased a new relationship with a mystery man. So, who is she dating? There are a few theories floating around.

Bobbi teased her new relationship in a video posted to her Instagram story — but while it did show off some sweet moments between her and her new beau, it strategically didn't show the man's face. What we can see is that he has dark hair, a beard, and dimples, and is much taller than Bobbi.

Her story has since expired, but the video was captured and reposted onto X (formerly Twitter) by NFL news aggregator Dov Kleiman, who made a bold statement regarding the identity of the man.

"Famous podcaster Bobbi Althoff has made her relationship public with [Arizona Cardinals] CB Sean Murphy-Bunting," he said.

In response, Sean himself was quick to deny the identification, simply saying, "That's not me."

However, it seems that folks in his comments aren't buying his story.

"[He] ain’t posted in two months and shut that s--t down immediately," one user said in Sean's comments. "That’s 100 percent him in that video."

Another wrote, "Lied so blatantly I thought you [were] telling the truth for a second." And hundreds of others responded with memes and gifs expressing their disbelief.

And we're not making any assumptions, but we have to admit that the man in Bobbi's video does look quite a bit like the NFL star.

It's unclear why exactly Sean would deny his relationship with Bobbi if it really was him in the video, but regardless, fans think they have him pinned.

Even before Bobbi's Instagram story, she and Sean had previously sparked dating rumors after a video captured the football player carrying her out of the Barstool Sports Bar in Nashville.

They then entered the back of an SUV together, which drove away.

At the time, Bobbi took to her Instagram story to explain that Sean was just a "good friend" who was looking out for her while she was intoxicated — but whispers of their romance had already started to spread.

Aside from Sean, other theories about Bobbi's new boyfriend have named former New York Jets player Cedric Ogbuehi, who also denied the rumors in a TikTok comment: "This is not me or Sean LOL."

To this, Bobbi herself replied with a series of exclamation points.

While Bobbi has confirmed she's not dating any NFL players, she seems smitten with her mystery man. In November 2025, the pair posted a TikTok of them dancing in the middle of a room with a Dancing With the Stars voiceover. The post received tons of traffic, including comments from critical fans who scolded Bobbi for "leaving her family."

Although she received flack for going public with her relationship, she seems to be focused on her truth. In an interview with Nick Cannon for his podcast, Nick Cannon @ Night, Bobbi explained she had been "single for two years" before dating her boyfriend and has been taking things slow with their relationship, stating her two kids she shares with her ex-husband don't even know the full scope of her and her boyfriend's romance.

"I didn’t introduce any of the other people where it was more casual that I was talking to, but once it was serious, and it was someone who I wanted to be in my life every day," she explained in August 2025. "But to this day, they still think he’s just a friend of mine.”