We Have Some Sad News About Katie and Derek From 'Married at First Sight' [SPOILERS]

In a promo for the 'Married at First Sight' reunion episode, we learn that Katie may have had an affair — according to Derek. Is it true? Are Katie and Derek even together still?

Gina Vaynshteyn - Author

Apr. 16 2020, Updated 9:23 p.m. ET

katie affair marriage at first sight
Source: Instagram/Lifetime

In not-so-shocking news, we recently learned that Katie from Married at First Sight possibly cheated on her husband Derek. The troubled couple from Season 10 agreed to work on their relationship, but it was honestly clear from the get-go that Katie's heart just wasn't in it (she literally said that herself in an episode, but added that she wasn't ready to give up yet). In a promo for the Married at First Sight reunion (airing next Wednesday), Derek announced Katie is having an affair.

Article continues below advertisement
married at first sight
Source: Instagram/Lifetime

Is Katie from Married at First Sight really having an affair?

It's true that Katie Conrad and Derek Sherman, both 26 years old, have had non-stop issues in their relationship. Katie claimed that Derek was immature and never showed romantic initiative. On the show, Katie explained, "So, Derek had tried, one time, and I felt like it was just so forced." Early on in the season, Katie even admitted that she was still in love with her ex (she supposedly got over it). Could Katie's concerns about Derek's lack of intimacy and her feelings for her ex mean she cheated? Most likely.

Article continues below advertisement
katie derek reunion
Source: Lifetime

Derek, on the other hand, claimed that as hard as he tried, Katie always turned him down. "I felt frustrated. There have been time and time again I've tried giving her romantic attention, but half the time she's either not feeling it, it's that time of the month, or we just had an argument that day," he said. Plus, he adds that Katie's love for conflict doesn't exactly turn him on: "Maybe it's just me, but I don't get sexually excited after our arguments."

Article continues below advertisement

Derek also made the point that Katie's jealousy issues were a pretty big problem in their relationship. "I started asking myself if this was how it was going to be if I ever had some of my closest friend over," he said, referring to Katie's disapproval of him getting closer to fellow Married at First Sight cast mate, Taylor Dunklin. "I understand that I could do a better job of making her feel more special than everyone else if we're all hanging out. But is it really that bad if I'm able to enjoy myself in a conversation with someone that isn't her?"

katie derek
Source: Instagram/Lifetime
Article continues below advertisement

Despite their issues, Derek was adamant that he wanted to stay married and try to make their relationship work.  Was that effort good enough though?

Spoiler alert: Here's what is really going on with Katie and Derek.

Of course this should be taken with a grain of salt (and we'll find out for sure if this is true or not next Wednesday), but according to Daily Soap Dish, Katie and Derek called it quits before the reunion special was filmed. This could explain why both Katie's and Derek's Instagram accounts are private. Even their Golden Retriever Jaxon's Instagram page is private! Y'all are hiding something, and if it's truly what we think it is, then Katie and Derek are certainly dunzo. 

Article continues below advertisement
katie derek puppy
Source: Instagram/Lifetim

Daily Soap Dish reported that they learned of the breakup because "social media and leaked news point to the couple's divorce" and Soap Dirt confirms this. But was it because Katie had an affair, or because the couple was just clearly not compatible? Maybe a little bit of both? Watch the promo for the reunion episode below:

Article continues below advertisement

Tune in to the Married at First Sight reunion on Lifetime, which airs next Wednesday at 8 p.m. EST.

More from Distractify

Latest Married At First Sight News and Updates

    Opt-out of personalized ads

    © Copyright 2023 Distractify. Distractify is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.