‘Miss Scarlet & the Duke’ Is Set in the Past, but When Exactly Does It Take Place?

Sam Bramlett - Author

Feb. 5 2023, Published 1:56 p.m. ET

'Miss Scarlet and the Duke' is about the first female P.I. in London.
Source: PBS

Does 'Miss Scarlet and the Duke' take place in the same era as Sherlock Holmes?

The PBS show Miss Scarlet & the Duke follows Eliza Scarlet as she takes the reins of her family business and becomes a private investigator after her father's death. She finds the Duke, one of her father's old connections who's an investigator with Scotland Yard, and while he's dismissive at first, the two become friends and solve cases together. Most people are confused when Miss Scarlet introduces herself as an investigator as they can't imagine a woman doing the job. So, when did this story take place?

Article continues below advertisement

The costume design of Miss Scarlet & the Duke may give away when the story is set, as all the men are wearing suits and top hats while the ladies all wear long gowns with feathery hats. Or, perhaps the setting itself may give away the year, as horse-drawn carriages fill the dirty cobblestone streets of a London, lit by oil lamps. It's clear that Miss Scarlet & the Duke is set in the past, but is there an exact time when it takes place?

So, when does 'Miss Scarlet & the Duke' take place?

Eliza Scarlet slowly falls for the Duke and vice versa.
Source: PBS

'Miss Scarlet and the Duke' flips the dynamic of Holmes and Watson.

Miss Scarlet and the Duke is set in 1882 Victorian London, England. This is the same time period when Sir Arthur Conan Doyle set the Sherlock Holmes books. The time period was contemporary for the author, and figures like Jack the Ripper spurred interest in mysteries, cementing Victorian England as a stereotypical setting for detective stories. However, in this instance with Miss Scarlet & the Duke, the setting also serves to show how Eliza pushes on as an investigator despite discrimination.

Everyone around Eliza is constantly trying to put her in a box, and yet her resolve to do good by her father and prove herself to all the people doubting her prevents her from quitting. Miss Scarlet & the Duke uses the 1800s London setting to make Eliza a more compelling character —as someone who must rise above adversity. The dynamic of Victorian London's sexism also creates tension between Eliza and the Duke, which helps both of them grow and realize that they care for each other.

More from Distractify

Latest Television News and Updates

    Opt-out of personalized ads

    © Copyright 2024 Distractify. Distractify is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.