Blake Horstmann's Past Hookups Come Back to Haunt Him on 'Bachelor in Paradise'

Who did Blake Horstmann sleep with on 'Bachelor in Paradise’? Why the reality star's past hookups reportedly confront him on the show.

Gabrielle Bernardini - Author

Aug. 5 2019, Updated 7:59 p.m. ET

blake horstmann bachelor in paradise
Source: ABC

This season of Bachelor in Paradise has promised to be one of the best, filled with hookups, heartbreak, and even a few proposals. Audiences will watch as past Bachelor/ette contestants get a second (or possibly third or fourth) shot at love and spend a few weeks vacationing in Mexico together. 

"It's the best season we've ever had," host Chris Harrison said on the Bachelor Party podcast.

Article continues below advertisement

One reality star that will cause a bit of drama on Season 6 of the hit series is Blake Horstmann. In June, Reality Steve revealed that after just one week of filming “it’s the Blake Horstmann Show.” The spoiler guru has hinted that the reality star will juggle multiple women on the show and will be the "villain" of the island.

blake horstmann bachelor in paradise
Source: ABC
Article continues below advertisement

So, who did Blake sleep with on Bachelor in Paradise?

According to RS, Blake will receive the first date card this season and he uses it to ask out Tayshia. However, the romance is short lived when his ex and fellow Bachelor star Kristina decides to use her card to go on a date with him. After getting back from their date, his previous relationships cause a bit of drama on the island.  

Back in April, Blake reportedly hung out with Tayshia at Stagecoach; then, had sex with Caelynn and Kristina that same week. Two weeks before leaving for the show, he flew down to hang out with Hannah G. 

The ladies all find out about Blake’s past hookups and confront him. “Blake ends up giving his rose to Tayshia at the first rose ceremony, but after that tells Tayshia and Caelynn both that he’s there for Hannah and wants to pursue her,” Reality Steve informed fans. 

Article continues below advertisement

However, Hannah has reportedly moved on from Blake and is with Dylan. According to the spoiler guru, “Everybody knows Blake’s business at this point… and his reputation has taken a major beating.” Well, we certainly can’t wait to watch the drama unfold.  

blake horstmann bachelor in paradise
Source: ABC
Article continues below advertisement

Does Blake get engaged on Bachelor in Paradise?

Though Bachelorette Hannah Brown did not get her fairytale ending, these Bachelor Nation stars reportedly find their soulmate on Season 6 of the hit series. One major storyline this season will be Demi Burnett’s relationship with Kristian Haggerty. 

This is the first time the ABC series is featuring a same-sex couple on the show. “I know that I love this girl,” Demi says in the trailer. “I’m just so happy that I found her, and I can definitely picture being with her for the rest of my life.”

Article continues below advertisement
demi kristian engaged
Source: Instagram

Fans will also get to watch sparks fly between Chris Bukowski and Katie Morton. Though this is now the sixth time Chris has appeared on a Bachelor franchise show, it looks like he has finally found “the one.”  

The third engagement that will be featured on the series is that of Hannah Goodwin and Dylan Barbour. Sorry, Blake! 

Catch Bachelor in Paradise Mondays and Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC. 

More from Distractify

Latest Bachelor in Paradise News and Updates

    Opt-out of personalized ads

    © Copyright 2023 Distractify. Distractify is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.