Source: Barbara Nitke/NBC

Why Did Olivia Benson and Her Brother Fall Out? A Necessary 'SVU' Recap



Season 21 of Law and Order: Special Victims Unit is proving to be Dick Wolf's finest, and neither the writers nor the squad show any signs of slowing down. Oct. 31's "Murdered at a Bad Address" is bringing back a 16-year-old case, as well as a few "ghosts from the past" who are back — perhaps with a vengeance.

Article continues below advertisement

The case in question is a double homicide of a mother and daughter to which two teens confessed. However, new DNA evidence shows a third accomplice — one who was never caught. The team must now go back to old witnesses and comb through their evidence in order to bring the perp to justice after all these years.

And while dealing with this doozy of a case, Captain Olivia Benson must also contend with a ghost from her past: her brother, Simon Marsden. 

So, who is Olivia Benson's brother? Here's the recap you'll need.

Article continues below advertisement
Source: Barbara Nitke/NBC

Here's what you need to know about Olivia Benson's brother, Simon Marsden.

While out getting Noah some ice cream, Olivia and her son are approached by Simon, her somewhat estranged half-brother. Simon is clearly desperate to reconnect with his sister and meet his nephew, and while Olivia is hesitant at first, she eventually gives in and agrees to get lunch.

Article continues below advertisement

We first met Simon in Season 8's "Philadelphia" when Olivia tracks him down and reveals the truth about their father: that he raped Olivia's mother and that she and Simon are half-siblings.

While Simon initially has trouble coming to terms with this shocking fact about his dad, he eventually comes around and the two bond.

Source: NBC
Article continues below advertisement

Soon, Simon is brought into the precinct to participate in a lineup for a rape case. Simon maintains his innocence, and it's only when Detective Stabler finds out that the lead investigator is someone from Simon's past that Olivia begins to believe Simon's story. Things don't go well for Simon's case, and at the end of the episode, he goes on the lam with Olivia's help.

Later that season, Olivia fully risks her career to protect Simon after she finds out that he was framed. Olivia tries to get the officer framing her brother to confess and eventually clears Simon's name.

Article continues below advertisement

Eventually, Simon moves back to New York where he begins a relationship with a woman named Tracy. They have children, including a daughter, who Simon names Olivia after her aunt. But when Simon gets into trouble with the law again, this time for drugs, his kids are taken away by Child Protective Services.

Source: NBC
Article continues below advertisement

Olivia gets then-DA Bayard Ellis to help get Simon's drug charges dropped, but Simon loses faith in the system and believes that he'll never get to see his children again.

This leads to a drastic action in which Simon convinces Tracy to kidnap their kids from foster care.

The couple quickly gets caught, and while Bayard is able to get Simon's charges reduced, he's put on probation and isn't allowed custody or unsupervised visits with his children for three years.

It's clear from Olivia and Simon's short but eventful relationship that Olivia may be justified in being cautious around her brother, especially with Noah involved.

Article continues below advertisement

But while he might have acted erratically in the past, Simon — now "clean five years" — appears sincere in his wishes to reconnect. When Olivia asks about his children, he responds, "I don't know. You know Tracy took the kids so I haven't seen her or them since I last saw you."

Even when Olivia tries to decline his invitation to lunch, Simon begs her. "Don't, don't say no," he pleads. "You're my only family."

Simon seems to just want to reconnect with his sister, but is there more to the story? Find out when Law and Order: SVU's "Murdered at a Bad Address" airs Thursday, Oct. 31 at 10 p.m. on NBC.

More from Distractify

More From Distractify