This Controversy Made Oprah Drop 'My Dark Vanessa' From Her Book Club

Kate Brierley - Author

Mar. 10 2020, Updated 2:10 p.m. ET

My Dark Vanessa is Kate Elizabeth Russell’s debut novel and a seven-figure book deal that's all anyone can talk about. It follows a 15-year-old's love affair with her 42-year-old teacher. 

With a 4.3 reader rating on Goodreads, it's about "exploring the psychological dynamics of the relationship between a precocious yet naïve teenage girl and her magnetic and manipulative teacher.”

Clearly, My Dark Vanessa explores a taboo subject. But that’s not what's bringing the book drama.

Article continues below advertisement

So what’s the ‘My Dark Vanessa’ controversy all about?

The biggest buzz around the novel comes from the fact that Oprah’s Book Club picked it up — then suddenly dropped it.

“Ultimately we did not end up moving forward with it as a book club selection,” a spokeswoman shared with AP News.

But why? Well, the book came under fire by another author on Twitter. 

Article continues below advertisement

Latinx writer Wendy C. Ortiz’s memoir Excavation was released in 2014 and covers her five-year sexual relationship with her eighth-grade English teacher as a teenager.

On Jan. 19, Wendy took to Twitter to call My Dark Vanessa a “white woman’s book of fiction that sounds very much like Excavation.”

She later told followers, “I’m uninterested in reading a book that sounds like a fictional take on a reality I lived. Especially after the author, under duress of public opinion, let me know she had read and enjoyed my book in 2015.”

The similarities in question sparked an investigation into whether Kate plagiarized, but reviewers found no evidence of it. Kate also says the novel is based, in part, on her own experiences.

Article continues below advertisement

Wanting no part of the drama, Oprah said she did not want to wade again into controversies that took away attention from the books themselves.

In response, Kate’s publisher, William Morrow, issued a statement saying they were “disappointed by their decision but thrilled to see the incredible response from early readers.”

Article continues below advertisement

What does ‘My Dark Vanessa’ have to do with ‘American Dirt’?

When Oprah says she doesn’t want to “wade again” into controversies, the operative word is “again.” Oprah recently came under fire for her book club pick American Dirt.

The Jeanine Cummins novel is about a Mexican mother fleeing to the U.S. border and was widely criticized for “cultural appropriation and the perpetuation of racial stereotypes.” 

The backlash was so severe that Oprah, Jeanine, and some of the book’s harshest critics held a forum that is available on Apple TV Plus.

Source: Getty Images
Article continues below advertisement

Here’s what Oprah says about all the 'American Dirt' drama:

Oprah openly addressed the controversy, but wants to avoid having to do so in the future — hence her decision to steer clear of My Dark Vanessa.

Of the book selections she makes and the American Dirt drama, she says, “This has actually caused me to pause about who’s writing it: Am I going to have to spend the next two months defending the writer, defending the writer’s right to write the book, or can we actually talk about the story?”

“I’m not going to play it safer, but I’m not going to wade into water if I don’t have to... this has taken up a lot of my energy, a lot of her (Cummins’) energy, and it’s taken the attention away from the real reason I want people to read books.”

Her next selection is due to be announced in April.

More from Distractify

Latest Apple TV Plus News and Updates

    © Copyright 2023 Distractify. Distractify is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.